Monday, March 2, 2020

Conclusion



Image result for penny marshall cindy williamsI wrote over five months ago, "I want to talk about how L & S, and Laverne and Shirley as characters, related (or failed to) feminism and a less political sisterhood.  I want to figure out why I'm still a Lavenny (Laverne + Lenny) shipper and whether that's justified.  I want to see how I really feel about what I at the time (my freshman year in high school) referred to as the "Laverne & Laverne" season.  I want to gasp at guest stars, even ones I know to expect.  I want  to marvel at the cluster of Northeast accents in Milwaukee.  And I even want to cringe at Garry Marshall schmaltz.  Most of all, I want to recount the experience, in broadcast order."

  • While I haven't addressed feminism in every episode, I do want to say that having two female leads (albeit ably supported by mostly male regulars), on what was one of the most popular shows in America, was in itself an inspiring sight, and that Penny Marshall went on to become a successful film director does mean something.  Laverne & Shirley were like sisters, in good and bad ways, sometimes supporting each other and sometimes working against each other.  (And this is true of Penny and Cindy behind the scenes.)  Was Laverne & Shirley as a show feminist?  Yes and no.  It sent mixed messages about sex and love, and work and success, but it was also about two very different women who were people, in a way that not every female character was on television in that era.  Both women were gorgeous in approachable ways, but they weren't just about their appearances.
  • Tracing the meandering path of Lavenny, and other ships, has been one of the most interesting aspects of this project.  Why was I a Lavenny shipper?  Because Penny Marshall and Michael McKean had incredible onscreen chemistry when their characters absolutely weren't required to, sometimes not even allowed to.  Laverne and Lenny as characters balance each other in a different way than each character does with her/his best friend, and they often bring out the best in each other.  The show wasn't designed for this ship, not like "will they or won't they?" Tony & Angela on Who's the Boss?, and sometimes Lenny and Laverne had other attractions, momentary or more serious.  But it's easy to see why I and so many others are invested in their frustrating relationship, more than we are in Shirmine or Fredna or, hell, the weird ships like Fronda and Carmine/Squendelyn.  (Squiggy/Beehive Girl though remains OTP!Endgame!)
  • Sadly, there was not enough of Laverne, particularly as we knew her, in Laverne & Laverne.
  • Oh, did I gasp at guest stars!  So many, from kind of obscure to "Jeff F***ing Goldblum!" as I put it on Facebook.
  • Seriously, as someone wrote on Youtube once, why is everyone in the '50s Italian?
  • I cringed but I was also sometimes warmed by the schmaltz, if it was earned rather than Garry M trying to shoehorn it into an abomination like "The Monastery Story."
  • I've recounted the experience, in broadcast order, trying to recall what I thought at the time but also finding that this series really was a lost part of my youth, not irrevocably lost but distant in so many ways.  
  • Thank you for reading my revisiting of Laverne & Shirley.  I could stay longer, tell you what I really think of Laverne & Shirley XXX: A Dream Zone Parody (short version, "Why doesn't Laverne have an accent?"), and the legacy of the show and all that.  But I'm off to read Garry Marshall's My Happy Days in Hollywood, including the chapter called "Schlemiel!  Schlimazel!  Laverne and Shirley Are Driving the Writers Crazy."

10 comments:

  1. Yay! You made it (also yess Squig and Beehive Girl!)

    I've always said the answer to "why Lavenny?" is simple: Laverne's relationship with Lenny is more nuanced and growing and chemistry-laden and even than most of her relationships with her canonical beaux (exceptions: Norman Hughes, Sonny, Randy). She goes from being repulsed by the notion of touching him in season 1 to being touched by his proposal in season 2 to using him as a confidante by season 3 to being all over him in season 6 to "marrying" him in season 7 (in TE) - that is both growth and a frustrated romance arc alike. (I am, however, still on the boards "Shirley should've just married Carmine after eight freaking seasons come on GM" and "Shirley and Squiggy would've had hilarious hate sex."). Plus when a show gives you three canonical marriage proposals and you leave a door open like you do in "Lenny's Crush," there's a vaccum there.

    I was hoping you'd do the two reunion shows too!

    YOU WATCHED THE PORN PARODY I'M SCREAMING. Everyone in the fandom has. It is, in a word, something else (and the only place Lenny/Squiggy/Laverne currently exists in any format).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anyone could follow a DeFazio halfway across the country, yet who but BG would follow Squiggy?

      Well, you wrote a whole manifesto on "why Lavenny," so yeah. We get to know Norman and Sonny a bit (Randy not so much, for obvious reasons), but we don't get seven years of their relationships with Laverne.

      I'm fine with Shirmine, I've just never (in over four decades) been invested in it. LOL about S/S hate sex. I guess that's implied in "Perfidy in Blue."

      I thought about reviewing the handful of books, Youtube clips, and so on, but where does it end? Still, I could probably do the two reunion shows, since they are sort of extensions of the original series, but first I want to do my marathon.

      LOL, I would've thought some in the fandom would be like, "Ew, porn, gross!" I saw it a couple years ago. (I like porn parodies, although I'll fast-forward through some of the sex to get back to the non-smut sometimes, and Anthony Rosano is always fun, there as Carmine Ragusa.) It is extremely low-budget and to some extent low-effort. I'd have to watch it again to give a fair assessment, but, yeah, Laverne not having a Brooklyn accent was actually my biggest gripe. (Rosano does a dead-on Tony Danza in other parodies btw.)

      Delete
    2. Exactly!

      Hah, truth, but I always have a new angle on that thing. And YEP.

      *on board the ships I meant. Now see, for me it's not my main pairing, but I still think the payoff would've been phenomenal.

      Yay! I kind of wanted to hear what you thought about the reunion sketch.

      HAH! Well, my side of fandom's very porn positive (I'm the person who wrote orgyfic at one point) in general! We all passed it around when it came out and were disappointed about Laverne getting spitroasted by Lenny and Squiggy for awhile instead of a solo Laverne/Lenny scene. I love Tommy Pistol and he's the only person on the planet I know who could play Squiggy and Ash Williams from Evil Dead and make both performances credible!

      I will say though that the actress did have the Laverne attitude down right.

      Delete
    3. The '95 reunion is on Youtube, and I have skimmed bits of it in the past few months. All I see on YT of the '02 "Together Again" special is a few crappy-looking minutes.

      I think that's wonderful that Lavenny is still so fresh and interesting to you after all this time and analysis. As for Shirmine, the audience would've gone crazy with joy if it had happened, and I would've felt some sense of closure, but it couldn't have matched what I felt in the studio audience when Mork proposed to Mindy!

      Oh, when you said "everyone," OK, chuckle. I recall porn!Squiggy having more lines than porn!Lenny, which is a shame because Seth Gamble is surprisingly good as Danny Zuko and Bam-Bam Rubble. (And, yes, it feels weird to be discussing this.) It did feel like there were actually little Lavenny moments, the way the Laverne actress said Lenny's name (sigh, without an accent), but yeah, what we got was a threesome. Tommy Pistol is fun in "The Nanny" parody, where he and the Val actress apparently are just ad-libbing "New York" lines during their sex scene.

      Shoot, I'm going to have to blog about "LASXXX," aren't I? OK, after the '95 reunion special.

      Delete
    4. I'm going to dig around and see if I can get you a better copy - mine's on an old VHS tape. You need to see it, if only so you can see everyone's (canonical?) fates and hear Lenny's last "(words!), Laverne."

      Aww! Yep, exactly, and they would've.

      Hah! We are a fandom thirsty for content, the porn parody will do (and hah, ditto!). And now I need to rewatch that scene just to notice the little moments.

      I'm doubly not shocked he did that. The guy's talented.

      YAY

      Delete
    5. Also: first podcast is probably going up next weekend.

      Delete
    6. Ooo, how exciting about the podcast! Are you going to do every episode like the HD people are or just ones you find interesting?

      I have a working VCR, if that helps.

      I may've been projecting the Lavenny, but that's what I recall. Re Tommy Pistol, it's honestly the only interesting scene in the whole movie, and has nothing to do with the main "story." Sigh, I'll take one for the team and stream "LASXXX" sometime in the next few weeks.

      Delete
    7. Yep, every ep!

      Hmm, I'll see if I can get you a copy somehow. I'm trying to poke around and see if anyone actually has it.

      Muahah have fun!

      Delete
    8. How fun! Please send me the link when it's ready.

      Re the "parody," at the time I watched it, I had seen just bits and pieces of L & S in the last few decades, so I don't know if my recent revisiting will make it better or worse to see something that half-assed (and bare-assed). But what the heck, if you want to read the post, I'll do it.

      Delete

Angel Face

Once again, I'm reluctantly writing another non-obituary for a star of Laverne & Shirley .  Three times in just over three years is ...